========================== Results: Ravenloft Ratings ========================== Compiled by: brooks@odie.ee.wits.ac.za (Goth) [Note: This file is one section of the ratings posted on December 22, 1994 to rec.games.frp.dnd; it is included in order to make the publically available ratings as complete as possible.] ============== Points Ratings ============== In order for a product to appear on the points rating table, it must have at least five votes. Products are listed in points order, from highest to lowest. /-------------------------------------------------------\ | - Key - | | | | Score = the product's average rating | | Low = the lowest rating anyone gave this product | | High = the highest rating anyone gave this product | | Voters = the number of people who rated the product | \-------------------------------------------------------/ Note: Results for the 1st Edition modules are included in the results summary for the 1st Edition AD&D products. Product Score Low High Voters ------- ----- --- ---- ------ RM4: House of Strahd 8.6 6 10 7 RA1: Feast of Goblyns 8.4 7 10 5 RR3: Van Richten's Guide to Vampires 8.1 5 10 10 RM2: The Created 8.1 6 10 7 RQ1: Night of the Walking Dead 8.0 7 9 5 MC10: Ravenloft 7.8 6 10 12 The Awakening 7.8 7 9 6 RA2: Ship of Horror 7.7 7 8 6 RR5: Van Richten's Guide to Ghosts 7.5 5 10 8 Van Richten's Guide to the Created 7.5 5 10 8 Dark of the Moon 7.4 6 10 6 RM1: Roots of Evil 7.3 4 9 7 RR6: Van Richten's Guide to the Lich 7.3 4 9 7 Forbidden Lore 7.3 6 9 6 RQ3: From the Shadows 7.3 5 9 6 RR2: Book of Crypts 7.2 5 10 7 Castles Forlorn 7.2 6 9 5 RR1: Darklords 7.1 5 10 8 RR7: Van Richten's Guide to Werebeasts 7.0 4 9 7 Realm of Terror 6.9 4 9 23 MC15: Ravenloft II: Children of the Night 6.9 3 10 8 RR4: Islands of Terror 6.6 4 9 7 New Edition Ravenloft Campaign Setting 6.3 2 10 10 RQ2: Thoughts of Darkness 5.2 3 7 5 ======== Comments ======== This next bit is a selection of comments people have sent in. I've removed some remarks which were very similar, especially for products which provoked large quantities of comment and I've done some minor editing for grammar and spelling. Other than that, this is how they were sent in. Boxed Sets and General Comment ------------------------------ I really liked Ravenloft, possibly the best thing about 2nd Edition even though the domain lords, with the exception of Strahd and Lord Soth are wimps and barely worth most PCs time. However, if a clever DM has the guts, they can try and mix the same sort of air that a well run Call of Cthulhu game can have. Where Ravenloft suffers the most is perhaps that it falls apart too quickly when the PCs get past 9th or 10th level, most other game worlds are the same, especially Krynn. This cannot be compensated for as was attempted in in Dark 'Gamma World meets Rifts' Sun, Munchkinism doesn't work in AD&D, most characters should be retired after 18th to 20th level. Anyways, Ravenloft works well for PCs between 3rd and 8th level and can make a good stop over during a larger adventure, say in the Realms or Krynn. The DM, unless the PCs are aware that the game is going to be played that way, shouldn't go out of his way to drive the players mad. On the whole, I give the entire Ravenloft campaign setting a '7', probably the highest rating I can give any 2nd Edition piece. Forbidden Lore was wonderful. The dice seemed like a last-minute add-on, but the rest was superb, especially expanded rules on curses and Powers checks. Can't help but be a little disappointed by Castles Forlorn. The setting itself is well-detailed and very good, but the adventure hooks just weren't there for me. In general I like the feeling of Ravenloft, but there is often limits inherent to TSR's marketing policies that limit its usefulness. The monsters are were originally well done, but have now become more cardboard cut-outs of classic gothic horror works. The Van Richten's Guide series appear to have some use, but seem like TSR rip-offs of White Wolf material than anything else. The modules were good, and the short crypt adventures are pretty good. But the many world-specific domains (Dark Sun, Spelljammer) are a little strained. The whole world is better as a series of encounters than a world in and of itself. I take the best of the domains and transplant them into "real" campaign worlds (like the Known World). I'm looking forward to using this. Full of possibilities, and nice things to launch on PCs who fall into the dark side of the Force(tm). Ravenloft was OK, but should not have been another setting. In my view, this has sharply limited its usefulness, despite a generally good concept. Not as rich or detailed as other settings. Also, its lords were either pushovers or sure-fire party killers. Ravenloft is the only one of the campign settings that I have. It was rather hard to mark, as the setting was so cool, but the set itself so poorly put together. Not bad, but a little vague on world description (too much in too little space), and perhaps set a little too far forward in science for my tastes (17th-19th century). Ravenloft, I think, depends too much on the DM's own ability to strike terror into his players. The setting is meant to help you with that kind of stuff, Ravenloft didn't as much as one would want. I loved to play in Ravenloft as a player, especially on Friday the 13th... Supplements ----------- Use the creatures from MC10 on a foggy night in WaterDeep and watch the players who memorize monster stats scream :-) MC 10 has a good mix of monsters, from low-powered monsters to master vampires. MC 15 is nice for generating adventure ideas from the monsters, but nothing is so unique a creative DM couldn't have come up with it. The plots in RR2 are usable most of the time though the adventures for the low levels are much better than the ones for the high levels. A comment on the reason for rating VRGtV a "10": Yeah, I'm the same guy that gave "10"s to FOR2 and Menzo. What can I say? I'm horribly, horribly biased. I admit it. I love vampires too. MC10, the obligatory Ravenloft MC, was just kind of there. Most of the creatures were run-of-the-mill spooky types, or filled in gaps from the MC system. MC15, Ravenloft Compendium II, contains some very compelling characters, and showcased one of Ravenloft's strengths. Individualizing opponents is one of the primary tools for making them "better" (read: more disturbing for the players). Although most of the NPCs are standard monster-types, all of them have a wonderfully twisted history which makes them much more than "ordinary." A very, very good work. Darklords gave needed detail on major lords, as well as other new lords that were very interesting (Ebonbane, the House on the Hill). The new lords in this book never made it to the New Edition; grab this while you can, Ravenloft DMs! Book of Crypts contains maybe one or two decent adventures; the rest is of lower quality than I would have expected. Van Richten's Vampires contains rules for vampires that I now consider essential, and use even in non-Ravenloft games. As with MC15, the designers of Ravenloft realized that individualizing the foe (in this case, so that you aren't sure how to defeat it) makes for rich horror. Islands of Terror is another hit-or-miss product, like Book of Crypts. A couple of the islands show imaginative design, but others should have been excluded. Not on my list as a can't-live-without RL product. Van Richten's Guide to Ghosts seemed hurried to me, but the information there is valuable all the same. Included here is a system for codifying all incorporeal undead, while making each unique; I like it a lot. Van Richten's Guide to the Lich is another superb VR's Guide. Can't write enough praise about it. Takes the demi-lich to a whole new level of power; now it's a foe worthy of the years it takes to become one. Liches themselves receive such detailed treatment that this one is a must-have for any campaign featuring a lich as a major opponent. Werebeasts was very good but suffered slightly from its (necessary) treatment of different wereforms. All told, though, the information adds tremendously to the understanding of these creatures. Van Richten's the Created is achingly good; golems in Ravenloft receive such detailed treatment that it's impossible to put down. Ancillary sections on golems other than flesh seemed like add-ons, but this too was necessary since flesh golems are so much easier to make (from Van Richten's point of view). Here, finally, is the reason WHY Adam turned on Dr. Mordenheim, and WHY a golem in Ravenloft is such an intractable foe. Van Ri