Church fighting IRS over anti-war sermon won't give up documents
PASADENA, Calif. - An
Episcopal church's decision Thursday not to cooperate with an IRS
investigation into an anti-war sermon delivered before the 2004
presidential election sets up a high-profile confrontation between the
liberal congregation and the IRS, which usually keeps such inquiries
The leaders of the 3,500-member All Saints Church voted unanimously
to resist an order to turn over documents related to the sermon, which
was given just two days before the election. The decision means the IRS
must decide whether to ask the Justice Department to pursue the case in
court. A judge would then rule on the validity of the agency's demands.
At a news conference at the church, the Rev. Ed Bacon, All Saints'
rector, said the action was taken to defend the church's
"responsibilities to criticize any public policies that demean or
destroy any member of the human family."
"Our faith demands that we say without fear or intimidation that
every human life is sacred and in God's eyes and heart every human life
is precious," Bacon said to loud applause and cheers. "Because these
responsibilities are required by our faith, they are therefore
Bob Long, senior warden at All Saints, said the 26-member vestry
voted unanimously early Thursday to reject the IRS' demands, which
included an interview with the rector, copies of e-mails and internal
correspondence and utility bills.
IRS spokesman Terry Lemons said he could not comment on a specific
case and would not say whether the agency would request a court hearing.
"We recognize the constitutional rights of freedom of speech and
religion," Lemons said in a statement. "But there is no constitutional
right to be exempt from federal taxation."
The dispute, which could cost the church its tax exempt status, has
attracted the attention of religious leaders on the right and left, who
say the IRS' actions could make it more difficult for them to speak out
on moral issues such as gay marriage and abortion during the midterm
At Thursday's news conference, church officials were flanked by
about 40 representatives of mosques, synagogues and other churches.
"We smell intimidation, it smells rotten, and we should not allow
any aspect of intimidation to be directed to any member of our great
country," said Maher Hathout, senior adviser of the Muslim Public
Rabbi Neil Comess-Daniels of Beth Shir Sholom synagogue in Santa
Monica suggested church supporters of all faiths contribute to a fund
to help All Saints pay its legal fees. Comess-Daniels made the first
pledge as Bacon looked on.
Under federal tax law, church officials can legally discuss
politics, but to retain tax-exempt status they cannot endorse
candidates or parties. Most who do so receive a warning.
The IRS, however, has promised tougher enforcement of the law during
this year's mid-term elections and in the 2008 election cycle.
The agency completed investigations of 90 tax-exempt churches and
charities in 2004 and found wrongdoing in 70 percent of the cases. Four
- none of them churches - lost their tax-exempt status. In 2005, the
agency began audits of 70 churches and charities and has 40 cases
pending so far this year.
Earlier this week, the conservative Alliance Defense Fund and the
Family Research Council sent letters to thousands of pastors informing
them about their right to speak to congregations on issues in this
year's elections, including abortion and gay marriage.
In recent years, Republicans in particular have teamed with
conservative evangelical leaders to motivate would-be voters, a
strategy credited with helping President Bush win re-election.
The dispute with All Saints centers on a sermon titled "If Jesus
Debated Sen. Kerry and President Bush" that was delivered by guest
pastor Rev. George Regas on Oct. 31, 2004. Though he did not endorse
either President Bush or Sen. John Kerry, he said Jesus would condemn
the Iraq war and Bush's doctrine of pre-emptive war.
"I believe Jesus would say to Bush and Kerry: 'War is itself the
most extreme form of terrorism. President Bush, you have not made
dramatically clear what have been the human consequences of the war in
Iraq,'" Regas said, according to a transcript.
The IRS reprimanded the church in June 2005 and asked that it promise to be more careful. Church officials refused.
According to the IRS, the only church ever to be stripped of its
tax-exempt status for partisan politicking was the Church at Pierce
Creek near Binghamton, N.Y., which was penalized in 1995 after running
full-page ads against President Clinton in USA Today and The Washington
Times in 1992 during election season.
All Saints member Sally Howard, of West Hollywood, said she agreed with the vestry's decision.
"The church should not back down from speaking to issues of peace
and justice. And if that means that the church is going to face loss of
its tax-exempt status, then that will be," she said. "We do not want to
be in that position of being neutral or being silent because of the
Howard said Regas never urged parishioners to vote for particular candidates.
"He has never, and he didn't that day, he's never stated that a particular person should be voted for," she said.
On the Net:
All Saints Church: http://www.allsaints-pas.org